The Electric Review


Home Page

Features & Profiles

From Rat's Notebook

Rat on Photography

Rat on Poetry

Rat on Reference

Rat on Music Books

Rat on Fiction & Nonfiction

On the CD Watch

Quick Picks

Industry News

Email Us

Home Page

Archive Review Page

The Columnists

Bob Dylan
The Daily Bleed

Empty Mirror Books

Expecting Rain

Allen Ginsberg

Harper Collins

Jack Magazine

Michael McClure

Shana Morrison

Small Press Distribution

The 3rd Page

Elsevier Health Science

Continuum International Publishing Group

Rat on Fiction & Non-Fiction

January 2004 Review

Archive Review Page

 

 DOUBT (A History). Jennifer Michael Hecht. Harper San Francisco. The questions and themes explored here are vast, almost bottomless: is there is a God? Did we evolve from another life form or from the hand of the Supreme Ruler? Should I question or just believe blindly? All this and more is the subject matter of this brilliant book by Jennifer Michael Hecht. Hecht is an accomplished poet and deep thinker whose work is breaking new ground by merging the poetic with the historical: This woman on a private journey, sorting out the craziness of the world by retracing its past, magnifying its grandest successes and most deplorable failures so we all might see and understand.

One of Hecht’s finest pieces (included on her web site jennifermichaelhecht.com) is a poem called "History;" it ruminates on Eve, looking back at the first lady’s road and wondering of the things that flowed from her bleeding heart through its inhuman mind:

"Even Eve, the only soul in all of time
to never have to wait for love,
must have leaned some sleepless nights
alone against the garden wall
and wailed, cold, stupefied, and wild
and wished to trade-in all of Eden
to have but been a child"

And from the slim and svelte lines of this poem, we can see the seed of Doubt take shape in the clusters of earthly space: More than anything else, this book looks back at the great doubters of the world, examining their wanderings through a maze of indecision and revelation:

"Descartes decides he will fight the evil spirit: he will force himself to believe that everything - the sky, the earth, colors, numbers, sound - is an illusion. Furthermore, ‘I shall consider myself as having no hands, no eyes, no flesh, no blood, nor any senses...I shall remain obstinately attached to this idea...’ "

Page- 316

And so you have it -- this is the matter of poetry, the warm knotted sinew of thought. As Hecht notes, thousands of years and many great minds have passed before us into thirsty mirrors of invisibility (Christ, Shakespeare, Galileo, Einstein, Aristotle), these men with brave and meaningful minds bent on figuring out themselves in relation to the world outside the window. Some of them rose gloriously like new born stars, while others only plummeted into flames of obscurity -- lost in the bitter taste of doubt, chained by the inability to see beyond consciousness into the throes of perfect and thoughtless enlightenment:

"We are in age of intellectual uncertainty and we are in age of science. We are in an age of cosmopolitan secularism and an age of ardent, doubt-conscious faith. We are marked by moral ambiguity. We investigate graceful life philosophies and various transcendentalist and therapeutic meditation..."

Page-483

What is the answer? Where do we go from here? Which road do I take? Many men before us were asking these same questions, and Hecht chronicles their journey masterfully here, her prose woven with intricate detail, time line building on time line to create not only a chronicle of doubt but also a chronicle of faith and passion, of dirty truth and beauty (as Bob Dylan wrote in his 1965 epic "Gates of Eden," it’s all only a mad quest to know "what’s real and what is not").

And perhaps that’s the ultimate lesson of this book: Men have been searching since the dawn of time and they search until death in the grave frees them. And perhaps the answer and the key to our earthly purpose is as simple as that.

Highly recommended for all college and public sector libraries. Would be appropriate as a teaching text in philosophy and history courses at the undergraduate level. One of The Electric Review’s picks of the year.

Order from amazon.com

divider

BUSINESS


 AUTUMN OF THE MOGULS: My Misadventures with the Titans, Poseurs
and Money Guys Who Mastered and Messed Up Big Media. By Michael Wolff. Harper Collins.
Michael Wolff , who writes a weekly column for New York Magazine ("This Media Life") is a journalist of great gusto and profound insight who holds nothing back. In Moguls, he gives us an insider’s break down of just what has gone wrong with the media, illuminating how the snakes took hold of the empire.

Simply, Moguls tells the story of the behind-the-scenes deal making that has rendered the media of this new America meaningless. Today, our biggest papers and magazines are not so much objective news gatherers dedicated to the dissemination of information, but instead, corporate traders looking to control the bank vaults; consequently, they dictate the things we’re allowed to see and hear. In one especially piercing passage on the rise of Martha Stewart, Wolff writes:

"Here is the first postmodern media empire. The Martha business is the ultimate guerrilla-marketing strategy: using the media to promote your media […] everything you did promoted everything else you did - you had to come up with an approach that allowed you to get paid for promoting yourself…"

What’s best about Wolff’s book and the way it’s written is that it’s about telling the truth. In one fine swipe of his pen, Wolff reminds journalists everywhere that it’s not about who you piss off, but about the reader’s right to know. This is why we do what we do -- we have an obligation to educate communities and individuals so that they can protect themselves and their personal liberties.

However, the ones who own newspapers and magazines and television stations aren’t interested in such noble endeavors. No sir. They want power and wealth and control of the market share. In reality, they’re human predators capitalizing on the public’s "need to know," manipulating the business side of journalism until nothing but the skeleton of a story remains. You see, they always leave a skeleton -- scant meat on the bone -- because they need something to sell.

Market share. Wall Street power. Advertising dollars. The monopolization of democracy. Michael Wolff had the guts to write a book about what’s really happening with the folks that sell us the news. Turn everything else off and focus your attention here.

Order from amazon.com

divider

RELIGION/SPIRITUALITY


 101 MOST POWERFUL PROMISES IN THE BIBLE. Steve and Lois Rabey and Marcia Ford. Warner Books. With another Christmas upon us, many will find it to be a good time to re-explore issues of faith and re-acquaint one’s self with the inner workings of the spirit. 101 stitches together in one volume some of God’s "promises" to his flock, giving those who may be experiencing a collapse of faith the opportunity to reclaim their relationship with Christ:

"...For just as the sufferings of Christ flow into our lives, so also through Christ our comfort overflows..."

(From--page 99)

The Rabeys and Ms. Ford present the material in short chapters, presenting one of God’s promises per chapter, and then analyzing it in terms that are relevant to life in the 21st century:

"...Keep me grounded on earth but looking forward to the hope of heaven."

(From--page 39)

This serves as the second installment in the Warner series that began with the 101 Most Powerful Prayers In The Bible in July 2003; due in February the 101 Most Powerful Proverbs in The Bible. Good gift choice for those grappling with questions of faith. Also good teaching tool for the young teen exploring Christianity.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 GOD’S BESTSELLER: William Tyndale, Thomas More, And The Writing Of the English Bible. Brian Moynahan. St. Martin’s Press. In the 16th century, William Tyndale wrote and published the first English translation of the bible, believing that his English countrymen deserved to be able to read the word of God in their own language. Even though Tyndale was accused of being a heretic, he would not be deterred from his beliefs. After Tyndale drafted his translation of the bible (an act directly contrary to laws that prohibited any independent interpretation of the scripture), he was hunted down by Sir Thomas More and eventually burned at the stake:

"As his obsession with Tyndale grew, More reviewed the body of evangelical books and had no hesitation in placing ‘fyrst Tyndales new testament father of them all by reason of his falase translatyng’. He saw a symphony of heresy in which Tyndale was ‘the basse and the tenour whereupoon [others] wold singe...’"

(From page 104)

William Tyndale’s life stands an example of how one’s personal religious beliefs can lead to being ostracized -- and even killed. Further, Tyndale’s life is an example of the risks we take when we step outside the bounds of the status quo to express a different point of view. Look at the Middle East -- look at what is happening in Iraq and in neighboring countries: men are killed and hunted down every day for daring to have an individualized way of looking at themselves in relation to society. William Tyndale’s story (which isn’t that widely remembered today) serves to remind us of the dangers in going against ‘church’ or ‘state.’

Brian Moynahan should be commended for his sound, sharp writing and for his analysis of this finger tip of history: In the end, Moynahan has written a book that is meant to leave its reader applying the lessons of William Tyndale’s final days to this 21st century version of the world.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 THE QUEST FOR THE TRUE CROSS. Carsten Peter Thiede and Matthew d’ Ancona. Palgrave. Quest is an ambitious book, for it sets out to answer the question of what happened to the cross after the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. Many historians subscribe to the thought that all "holy relics" in existence are nothing more than fakes feeding the insatiable human need for illusion. However, Thiede and d’Ancona come to contradcit this position in order to analyze a fragment of wood that is said to be from the headboard of the cross on which Christ died:

"In this book we have tried to extend this approach to the first symbols and sacred artefacts of the early Christian communities; to show the antiquity and deep signifigance of those symbols, and the care with which holy objects would have been safegaurded; and to demonstrate the absolute importance in early Christianity of such objects, of sacred locations and of their preservation. Naturally, legends, rumours and pure falsehoods accrued to their memory. But not everything that was said and written about holy relics and places was false."

(From page 154)

Obviously, it’s a difficult proposition to attempt to alter anyone’s personal belief system (and even more difficult to dissect the reasons as to why the icicles of these ideas formed in the first place). On this level, Quest is a bold and impressive book, for its authors choose to go against conventional thinking and lead us down a path where one has to truly believe in order to arrive at an answer; in actuality, we are travelling down a similar path that William Tyndale traversed centuries before. Read on: Thiede and d’Ancona encourage each reader to risk the walls of an open mind. In turn, you might be rewarded with the rediscovery of God along the way.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 SEX AND HEAVEN (Catholics In Bed and Prayer). John Portmann. Palgrave. The state of the Catholic Church is in disarray these days - with endless molestation scandals rocking the faith of its followers . Here, John Portmann has written an in depth book that looks at the way the Roman Catholic Church views matters sexual in nature -- analyzing just how realistic the Church’s moral expectations really are:

"Is sex just another issue, or is it the burning question of today? Certainly, Christianity has faced many challenges over the course of two thousand years (for example, Pelagianism, iconoclasm, and Islam). The Vatican has wrestled with various issues and lost (for example, the morality of slavery and the position of the earth in our galaxy). Are sexuality and gender simply the most recent in a long line of scrapes, then? Or can they be accurately portrayed as more potent than preceding crises? In increasingly secular times, it seems the one issue really capable of rallying the troops is sex. That in itself is perhaps a sufficient answer."

(From Page 52)

As many a psychologist has observed, sex is the one thing that shreds the human mind and renders it helpless. Many -- I’d venture to say most -- people are so confused about their sexuality and how they relate to others that they wander through life completely dysfunctional. But why? It all comes down to the concept of guilt. We are taught in church that you can’t get to heaven with a sinful, immoral, dirty mind. Further, the church teaches that if sex occurs outside the limits set by marriage it defiles both body and mind.

So, as we learn these things from our priests and from our parents the natural impulse for sexual release suddenly is blackened with guilt -- tarnished gone dark and hidden away under cold murky blankets in secret dreams. Just like that, we lose sight of ourselves and our faces and how to express ourselves. However, it’s not just the people going to church who are swimming in confusion: If the accusations of child abuse that have surfaced against hundreds of priests prove to be true, then it will quite forcefully demonstrate that the clergy is also fighting through questions of sexual identity/expression.

Sex and Heaven is a deep book; even though it is written in a very academic and distant way, it nonetheless confronts some very caustic issues and compels its readers to look at the church with practical, yet human, eyes. I don’t have any answers. But I think after reading Portmann’s writings that I am better able to see just what questions need to be asked.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 THE CONTINUUM HISTORY OF APOCALYPTICISM. Edited by Bernard McGinn, John J. Collins and Stephen J. Stein. Continuum. This fine selection just released by Continuum condenses the 1,500 page Encyclopedia of Apocalypticism published in 1998. This volume does a fine job of tracing the origins of Apocalypticism from the ancient world through modern times. “Apocalypticism,” a term which refers to a time when the world will end and God will judge his children, is the foundational idea behind Christianity (as well as Judaism and the Islamic faiths). Further, it is the true driving force behind the element of conscience and man’s understanding of the concepts of good and evil:

“Like the proclamations of John the Baptist, Cyprian’s letters to Bishop Lucius of Rome in 252 say that the sufferings of church leaders all over the empire simply make it clear that Christ is coming soon to confirm his faithful ones in joy. All these passages reveal how, in Cyprian’s hands, the imagery of the apocalyptic tradition - taken very much at face value - has become a powerful means of pastoral encouragement as well as a key to finding deeper meaning in the troubles of his time.” (Brian E. Daley; pages 229 & 230)

Given recent world events (the terrorist bombings in New York City and Washington DC in September 2001, the Iraq War in 2003), we can see how the belief that life is about to end propels human behavior. Those responsible for crashing the planes into the World Trade Center towers saluted God as they embarked on a journey that culminated in acts of savagery and barbarism. It may be hard to fathom, but these terrorists didn’t think that they were dying, but instead believed they were moving into a state of heavenly bliss, far beyond the mouth of the apocalypse.

Confused and dumbfounded on why things are happening? Well, it all comes down to how people interpret faith and their personal relationships with God, about how they fit into the holy mysteries of existence. Accordingly, the Continuum History sets out to explain the genesis of these ideas. In nursing this project to completion, the editors have done a magnificent job in synthesizing a vast amount of material and editing very complex essays, tying the book together in a seamless and, ultimately, a profound way. However, many will find that the tone of the writing is overly scholarly -- a style that is likely not to appeal to the general reader. Instead, this is a book for students of religion who are curious to understand the reasons why Man has developed in the manner in which he has. Would be an appropriate text at the University level in Theology or Religions of The World courses. Invaluable reference text for all libraries in the Religion and Spirituality sections.

To order go to amazon.com

divider


OF NOTE


 LEECHCRAFT: Early English Charms, Plantlore and Healing. Stephen Pollington. Anglo-Saxon Books. This is the most comprehensive study of the healing arts in the Anglo-Saxon world since Henry S. Wellcome's "Anglo-Saxon Leechcraft" (published in 1912 and long since out-of-print). Pollington’s book covers everything from healing through prayer and witchcraft to the use of plants as medicine -- an interesting and absolutely thorough exploration of the way cultures have evolved, using a classic reportage style to show how communities once dealt with the suffering of the sick. In these ancient worlds, much of daily life was predicated upon prayer, and people beckoned God forth though meditation and words, requesting that He heal them through the wondrous elements of nature:

"Blessing of the plants. All-powerful , eternal god who from the world’s beginnings set up and made all things, both trees of their type, and plants with their seeds, the same ones as you have hallowed, consecrating them with your blessing..."

(Page 247--From The Lacnunga Manuscript)

What’s best about Pollington’s book is the effortless and clear way that it is written and edited: Pollington is a master lecturer who knows how to present complex and layered material in a concise and thorough manner, always careful to place data in its proper historical context. Further, Leechcraft’s format includes a detailed index which allows the reader to search for specific information without needlessly wasting time. Complimented by Lindsay Kerr’s first-rate illustrations. Highly recommended as a teaching text at the college level for all history and anthropology courses that touch on the subject matter of early English healing.

Order from amazon.com

divider
 DEATH BY PRESCRIPTION. Ray D. Strand (with Donna K. Wallace). Thomas Nelson Publishers. Many Americans mistakenly believe that you can only get hooked to drugs on the street, believing that if your doctor is furnishing medications to alleviate health problems that the process is safe and without risk. And nothing could be further from the truth. Doctor Ray Strand’s new book, Death By Prescription, is a shocking and blunt analysis of the prescription drug business in the United States --a call to the government to begin revamping this system before more people are injured needlessly.

In this country, it has become common place for people to expect a pill whenever they feel ill or encounter changes within their bodies. In the short span of forty years, we’ve become dependent on medications to deal with our lives. Anti-depressants. Antibiotics. Pain killers. Acne creams. Lotions for your wrinkled skin. An endless list of medicines with very real consequences to each and every dose. Dr. Strand’s new book carefully begins to dissect this phenomenon, examining the risks to the consumer and what can be done about it:

“...In 1994, more than 2.2 million people required hospitalization because of serious reactions to medications. Even more troubling was the fact that more than 106,000 of these patiently actually died because of adverse drug reactions - reactions to properly prescribed and administered medications.”

And further:

“America’s number four killer is adverse drug reactions to properly prescribed medication, with more than 100,000 estimated deaths per year.” (Page 8)

So why is this happening? The answer is that selling people medication is big business. Selling people the illusion that their every problem is curable by magic potion is a business that generates over 300 billion dollars annually. Because of the huge dollars at stake, medications are often rushed to the market without the adverse potential of the drug completely known.

Strand, who has been a doctor for over 30 years, does a nice job in writing this book so that the material is understandable to the general reader. In his presentation, he uses patient studies/stories to illustrate his arguments and to show how the prescription drug trade has developed into such a potential mine field for Americans. I am sure there will be quite a few ney-sayers who will categorize Strand’s book as the ramblings of a doctor trying to push holistic medicine. But I think the majority of the criticism will come from those tied to the business of pharmaceuticals -- by those who generate a steady flow of income by promoting this process.

Upon finishing this book, many questions remain: Are drugs over-prescribed in this country? Should doctors use their prescription pads less -- as a final resort after other less drastic approaches have been evaluated? Does the Food and Drug Administration rush new medications to the market before the full effects to the consumer have been analyzed? Many many questions. And, ultimately, it is left up to each individual patient to govern himself and ask these questions before he swallows that first pill. The burden of responsibility lies with you, and with you alone.

If anyone in your household takes prescription medication, I highly recommend this book - it’s probably the most important consumer guide to hit the shelves in a long time. Also recommended to libraries in the public and university sector as an invaluable reference.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 MAYADA (DAUGHTER OF IRAQ). Jean Sassoon. Dutton. Mayada Al-Askari, a single mother with two kids, barely made enough money to survive by printing pamphlets on broken down computers. Her life in Iraq was non-descript and modest -- just one more hard-working Iraqi trying to get by. In hind-sight, this existence could never predict the suffering and tragedy that would quickly become Al-Askari’s life.

In the summer of 1999, Mayada Al-Askari was arrested by Saddam Hussein’s secret police and banished to the Baladiyat Prison, accused of circulating anti-government propaganda. The charges were obviously ludicrous -- the by-product of a dictator whose paranoia was ascending with the force of a bullet. As a prisoner, Al-Askari became just another “shadow women” -- these women who lived in the same cramped cell and endured constant torture without even knowing their “crimes”:

“The shadow women were so close that each woman was touching the woman in front and the woman in back, a train of terrified women...They quickly arrived at the end of the corridor and were herded like sheep through the narrow door. As they entered the room, a collective gasp swept through the line. The strange room was a cave. The walls were pitted and dark. Buckets lined the floors, containers filled to the top with urine. Human excrement was piled high....” (Page --163)

How would you survive such a hideous nightmare? Like Mayada and the others did: by looking backward into memories of sweeter times. By looking forward to the day when you might escape your captors and flee beyond time, unto a place where Hussein and his legacy do not exist.

We’ve heard alot about Iraq over the last 20 months -- too much in fact. However, this book switches gears. Written by Jean Sassoon (Princess: A True Story of Life Behind The Veil in Saudi Arabia) in a clear and inviting prose, it offers a first person account of the scope of the pain and suffering that for decades besieged these people. But the real core of the book is the way it poignantly depicts how women were treated under Hussein’s mighty rule. Startling and daring. You don’t need a lengthy critical summation from a reviewer. If you’re curious about what happened “over there,” buy this book.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 BRAVE MEN, GENTLE HEROES. Michael Takiff. William Morrow. Brave Men, by New York writer Michael Takiff, is one of the most unique “war books” to hit the shelves in quite awhile. Brave Men looks at war from the standpoint of fathers and sons - father’s telling stories of World II and their sons recounting the horrors of serving in the jungles of Vietnam. One group of men widely revered for saving the country and possibly the world, while the younger generation is all but forgotten for being tied to the indelible scar of disgrace that became America’s presence in ‘Nam.

However, Brave Men quickly moves beyond such political perimeters; in the end, this book is really about the soldiers who served the country, about the inhuman pressures men at war endure: “I was scared for the moment, because I just wanted someone to hold on to. That was one of my fears in the ‘Nam: dying out there somewhere alone. But I didn’t fear dying itself. In our culture we don’t believe that spirits and souls die. It is only the container that grows old, wears out, and dies...” (pages 287 and 288).

The mental demands of being in a war must be enormous --staggering. Those of us who have not had to go through such trials cannot truly comprehend what goes on “out there.” Can you imagine being shot at by countless riflemen at the same moment? Can you imagine having to make a split second decision to shoot someone or to throw your grenade before you’re shot dead? Can you imagine the taste of having to kill someone -- of being ordered to kill someone? Can you imagine the ghosts you’d see every night in your sleep?

Brave Men is about warriors. American warriors on the road to victory in the name of God. A statement of the self by the men who lived time in a foreign land. More than a memoir or remembrance, this book is vital today (as the country lives through Iraq - a war some have labeled “The Second Vietnam”).

Are you at all curious about what your uncle or father or brother went through? Read on: the demons that drove Captain Willard up river in Francis Coppola’s fictional Vietnam War epic “Apocalypse Now” are the same demons that live inside of all soldiers. That fear and regret , that hollow indecision of the moment. If you’re curious about these things, Mr. Takiff’s book will have great meaning for you.

Order from amazon.com

divider

 THE ANDROMEDA STRAIN & CONGO. Michael Crichton. Avon. These two selections by Crichton, both New York Times Bestsellers, are the finest thrillers on the paperback racks today. What stands out about them is the way that they immediately grip the mind like the hinges of a trap -- brilliantly conceived novels (little movies) that entertain and obsess until the only thing that matters is “what happens next?” And isn’t that exactly what a novel should do -- command its reader? Crichton (who also created the ER television series) chisels well formed plots and the suspense is always somehow real -- alas, believable. These books make great “small” gifts for the day commuter on their trip to and from work.

Order from amazon.com; also see www.michaelcrichton.net

divider


On The Sports Page


 

 PERFECT I’M NOT (Boomer on Beer, Brawls, Backaches, and Perfect Baseball). David Wells and Chris Kreski. William Morrow. Perfect I’m Not is the “tell-all” memoir of New York Yankees’ pitcher David Wells. Wells has been both a high-flying star and an also-ran in the major leagues, and this book relates his story in a ballsy tone -- discussing everything from sex on the road to being traded for Roger Clemens. The depth of Perfect comes in the fact that Wells and Kreski don’t dodge any subject matter -- instead they confront issues head-on, bringing the fan and casual observer straight into the locker room:

Spoiled and over-paid stars lacking in modesty and life skills. Grown men who haven’t grown up and faced themselves. Entertainers of the highest order misunderstood and isolated. This book has many layers, and it will leave some saying that this is exactly what’s wrong with sports in America -- too much money given to individuals who are not equipped to handle it. On the other hand, just as many readers will be riveted -- thankful for the inside look at the world of baseball, proud for the chance to glimpse the real Steinbrenner and learn about the inner mechanics of our national past-time. No matter which side of the fence you straddle, Perfect I’m Not is a fun read full of interesting tid-bits about baseball and stardom. I venture to predict that you will be entertained and educated from beginning to end. Highly recommended as a gift item for the sports fan on your list.

Photo courtesy of Harper Collins Publishing.

Order from amazon.com

 INSTRUCTIONS FOR SPORTS MEDICINE PATIENTS (with CD-ROM). Marc R. Safran (with David A. Stone and James Zachazewski. W.B. Saunders. Dr. Marc Safran of the University of California, San Francisco’s Department of Orthopedic Surgery presents a resource guide for physicians and medical therapists who work closely with injured athletes. This book provides an over-view of sports trauma, including descriptions of common injuries and discussions on the nature and causes of injury; also analysis on complicating risk factors, treatment recommendations and guides to prevention. Basically, Safran’s text is meant for the patient, in that these instruction sheets can be photo-copied or printed straight off the CD ROM and distributed to the injured. Safran’s writing is at all times clear, direct and user-friendly, offering the patient step-by-step instructions for treatment and rehabilitation. Illustrations augment the text throughout, and these are especially helpful when it comes time to begin therapy and exercise regimens. Many topics are examined, including fine segments on rotator cuff injuries (tennis and baseball players will find this material of note), as well as information on Anabolic Steroids and Amino Acid Supplementation. Appropriate for the general practitioner and the sports physician, as well as for physical therapists and collegiate medical staffs. Further recommended as a reference for libraries at the university level and in the private sector.

Order from amazon.com, or go to www.elsevier.com

divider



 

Website copyright 2002-2003 The Electric Review. All rights reserved.
Reproduction of material from any Electric Review pages without written permission is strictly prohibited.